
One of the most common tactics insurers use to reduce or deny car accident claims is to argue that the claimant’s injuries are the result of pre-existing medical conditions, not the accident. If you had a prior back injury, arthritis, neck problems, or other health conditions before the crash, the insurer may try to use that against you.
But Florida law has a clear answer to this tactic: the eggshell plaintiff rule.
What Is the Eggshell Plaintiff Rule?
The eggshell plaintiff rule — also known as the “eggshell skull” rule — states that a negligent driver must take the victim as they find them, with all their pre-existing medical conditions. If the accident aggravated a pre-existing condition or caused a more serious injury than would have occurred in a completely healthy person, the negligent driver is responsible for the full extent of that aggravation.
In plain terms: if you had a weak back before the accident and the crash significantly worsened it, the at-fault driver must pay for that worsening — even if a person without that pre-existing condition would not have suffered as serious an injury.
How Insurers Try to Use Your Pre-Existing Conditions Against You
Insurers have several strategies to minimize your claim when you have pre-existing conditions. They may argue that your current injuries are simply a continuation of your pre-existing condition, not the result of the accident. They may request all your prior medical records looking for any mention of similar pain or injuries. They may hire expert physicians to testify that your current symptoms are pre-existing. And they may offer very low settlements, arguing the accident only minimally contributed to your current condition.
How to Protect Your Claim
Be Honest About Your Pre-Existing Conditions
Do not try to hide your pre-existing medical conditions. Insurers will obtain your medical records anyway, and if they discover you were not honest, it will seriously damage your credibility. Instead, be transparent and let your attorney frame the narrative correctly.
Document the Change in Your Condition
The key in cases with pre-existing conditions is demonstrating that the accident made your condition worse. You need medical evidence showing your state before the accident and how it changed afterward. This can include prior medical records showing your condition level before the crash, post-accident records documenting the worsening, statements from your doctors about how the accident affected your condition, and your own testimony about how your symptoms changed after the crash.
Seek Medical Attention Immediately
If you have pre-existing conditions, it is even more important to seek medical care immediately after the accident. This establishes a clear timeline connecting the crash to the worsening of your condition.
Common Pre-Existing Conditions in Accident Cases
The most common pre-existing conditions insurers try to use against claimants include prior back and neck injuries, arthritis, herniated discs, fibromyalgia, chronic migraines, and prior knee or shoulder injuries.
In all of these cases, if the accident aggravated the condition, you are entitled to compensation for that aggravation.
Contact 305-EN-DOLOR Today — Free Case Evaluation
At 305-EN-DOLOR, we have experience handling car accident cases with pre-existing conditions throughout Miami and South Florida. We know how to present your case so that the eggshell plaintiff rule works in your favor.
We do not charge fees unless we win your case. Call 305-EN-DOLOR today for a free case evaluation. Se habla español.